CHA Home Page

 




 



Lucasfilm and PG&E flex their Power in Cow Hollow
(Cow Hollow Association newsletter article)

Go to the Update on Project and Action Items

Go to the Media Alert/Resolution to Board of Supervisors
Go to How to Get Involved
Go to Reponse to PG&E Letter
Go to Flyer to Cow Hollow Neighbors - Dec. 19, 2003

View EMF Fact Sheet
View Route Options

Project History

PG&E recently began work on a major “road-digging” power line project to supply Lucasfilm’s Letterman Digital Arts Center in the Presidio with 8 megawatts of power, enough to meet the needs of a small town or power 2,400 – 8,000 homes. According to PG&E project manager Gary Tognozzi, this is less than the 12 megawatts initially requested by Lucasfilm, up from the current supplied levels of 1-2 megawatts.

Lucasfilm's contract with PG&E requires that 3 megawatts of power be delivered to Letterman Digital Arts no later than July 1, 2004, 3.7 megawatts delivered no later than November 2004, and 4.2 megawatts by January 2005. These incremental increases are necessary to bring the new building’s systems and technology infrastructure on line by Spring of 2005 in preparation for the planned occupation in the Summer of 2005. PG&E has stated that it will take approximately twenty (20) weeks to complete the ten (10) block long trench down Filbert Street and needs to start trenching on Filbert in January 2004. PG&E has stated additional wires can be strung over existing power poles to supply the initial 3-megawatt need, but with the 3.7 megawatts needed by November 2004, this solution will be short-lived.

PG&E had hoped to run this power line down Greenwich Street from Fillmore to Lyon, but Greenwich Street has been dug up six times in the last two years, the maximum number allowed by law. The Greenwich Street residents were willing to accept this disruption ONLY if the Letterman Digital Arts power line could be coordinated with the undergrounding of the above ground utility lines. Greenwich residents have been campaigning for over fifty years for the undergrounding of their overhead utilities and had attempted negotiations with PG&E to align the two projects. PG&E stated that due to the limited time frame, they could not reengineer the project (from 8-18 months) or wait for Greenwich residents to secure legislation (Rule 20a funding). Since the coordination of both projects seemed unlikely and Greenwich residents were adamantly opposed to another major street disruption without the offsetting benefit of undergrounding, Ed Lee, Chief of DPW, pulled the Lucasfilm permit with the Mayor's urging until an alternative route could be chosen. The response from PG&E was to move the power line route up one block to Filbert Street. Both routes call for continuing the power line down Lyon Street to Chestnut.

CHA Concerns

Many Cow Hollow residents are concerned about the Letterman Digital Arts Center power line project for several reasons:

  • PG&E sent out a letter dated August 19, 2003 notifying their customers along Filbert and Lyon Streets that “construction will begin on a new feeder line to support electric demand supplying our customer located on the Presidio.” The letter did not state that the upgrade was solely for the purpose of the Letterman Digital Arts Center.

  • Various residents on Filbert Street did not receive notification from PG&E that the Letterman Digital Arts Power Line Project was proposed for their street.

  • There was no opportunity for public comment, only the offer to telephone PG&E for information.

  • The selected route is not in a straight line, but travels south from Bay Street on Fillmore for the distance of five (5) blocks, travels west on Filbert, then north on Lyon for three (3) blocks. A much more direct route would be to travel down Bay across to Alhambra, which turns into Francisco and continues directly to Letterman Digital Arts.

  • The net increase in blocks traveled to head south to Filbert and north again to Letterman Digital Arts is eight (8) blocks. The cost to travel the extra blocks is substantial, with estimates between $75,000 and $300,000 per block.

  • The southerly Filbert Street route travels on two (2) Muni Line routes and crosses four (4) vs. the Alhambra route which travels on zero (0) Muni Line routes and crosses four (4); the net is the Filbert Street route travels on two Muni Line routes with the resulting bus service disruptions.

  • There has been no community meeting led by PG&E, Lucasfilm, and the City of San Francisco to explain to the residents of Cow Hollow the rationale behind this circuitous route through a neighborhood located for the most part four blocks south of the most direct route.

  • There has been no discussion with the residents on the short and long range planning issues concerning this power line, its initial installation and impact on the residents, construction schedule, etc., any future maintenance, and any additional lines or improvements that could possibly require re-digging up the streets.

  • There has been no discussion with the residents on the short and long range health risks associated with the underground power line.

  • There has been no discussion with the residents as to why San Francisco neighborhoods need to suffer undue hardships for a construction project that is taking place in the Presidio, entirely on Federal land, which has access to a federal power agency.

  • The Letterman Digital Arts Center’s electricity requirements opens up the possibility of other adverse neighborhood impacts that future Presidio Trust development might impose. For this reason, any real estate development in the Presidio needs to be accompanied by an Environmental Impact Study and/or Environmental Impact Report for areas outside the Presidio.

The Cow Hollow Association passed a resolution at their Board Meeting on October 7, 2003 to address these concerns:

"The Cow Hollow Association strongly opposes the selected PG&E Power Line Route for the Letterman Digital Arts Center through the Cow Hollow neighborhood, currently on Filbert and Lyon Streets, requests that no work commence on the Filbert Street corridor, and requests that PG&E, Lucasfilm Ltd., and the City and County of San Francisco hold a neighborhood-wide meeting to discuss the areas of concern to the residents of Cow Hollow."

In conjunction with Mike Farrah of Supervisor Newsom's Office, the CHA has requested a meeting with PG&E, Lucasfilm Ltd., and DPW to discuss these issues.

Also please consider joining the CHA if you are not already a member to receive regular email updates about this and other happenings in your neighborhood.

CONTACTS:

PG&E - Gary Tognozzi 415-695-3381
2180 Harrison St, SF 94110
Fax 695-3332
cell 415-716-8046

Lucas Film - Chris Glennon 415-448-3522
Director of Corporate Real Estate and Operations
P.O Box 2459
San Rafael, CA 94912
FAX 448-3553

DPW - Ed Lee 415-554-6920
1 Dr.Carlton B. Goodlett Place
City Hall, No. 348
San Francisco, CA 94102
FAX 554-6955
edwin.lee@sfgov.org

DPW - Barbara Moy
875 Stevenson, Room 460
San Francisco, CA 94103